• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Law School Toolbox®

All the tools you need for law school success

  • Tutoring
  • Courses
    • Start Law School Right
  • Job Help
  • Law School 101
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • About

Is Your Open Memo Research Finished?

November 5, 2015 By Doretta McGinnis Leave a Comment

law school books

You’ve been researching your open memo, experiencing frustration, relief, and maybe even exhilaration along the way. But now you’re feeling fatigue and an unsettling sense that you’re not sure whether you’re done. What to do?

Don’t ask your professor, “How many cases do I need?”  There is no magic number of cases, but there is a core group of essential cases and a larger universe of potentially useful cases. Your professor expects you to find the essential cases and a smattering of other stuff. It’s likely that you’ve found too much. So first, you need to decide when to stop. Second, you need to analyze what you’ve found.

You’re done researching if . . . 

You’ve found mandatory authority on your issue. The best mandatory authority is not only from an appellate court in the relevant jurisdiction – it’s also recent and involves facts similar to those of your assignment. It is a rare legal writing assignment that does not involve cases meeting these criteria. You’ll know them when you see them.

You’ve found relevant cases with favorable and unfavorable outcomes. The purpose of a memo is to provide objective, balanced analysis of a legal issue or claim, giving you the opportunity to view a problem from all sides and to present both analysis and counter-analysis. To facilitate this goal, many memo assignments are based on essential cases that have varied outcomes; these outcomes are driven by the facts, which may be more or less analogous to yours. If all the cases you’ve found are favorable to your client’s position, you may have missed something along the way.

You’ve found the same cases over and over again. There are many paths through the research jungle; if you’re doing things right, they all lead to the same place. Using multiple research techniques provides a check on the process and increases the chances that you’ve found what you need. For example, you might find the same case(s) in secondary sources, by digesting, in annotations to a statute (if you have a statutory issue), by online key number searches, etc. If you’ve tried several techniques and gotten the same results, your research is likely complete.

Your cases are still “good law.” This means the cases you’re relying on have not been reversed or overturned. (What’s the difference? A case that is appealed will be reversed or affirmed.  An unrelated case may overturn the holding of an older case on the same issue.)  It’s crucial to check the subsequent history of every case you’re relying on in your memo. Citing an overturned opinion will hurt your grade; in the Real World, the consequences will be greater: malpractice and possible loss of your job. Trial court opinions, such as those of the Federal District Courts, require particular scrutiny, as they are the most likely to be appealed.

You’ve found the most recent cases that cite your key cases. In addition to making sure your cases haven’t been reversed or overturned, you need to follow the trail of cases that cite your cases. Theoretically, this could lead to a never-ending daisy chain of citations. Realistically, the cases that matter are those that cite your case for the relevant issue and that are (a) mandatory, (b) recent, and/or (c) provide detailed or different analysis on similar facts.

Next, carefully consider the following:

 Strong persuasive authority. Persuasive authority refers to cases from jurisdictions other than your own, or decisions of a trial court in your jurisdiction. The best persuasive authority is recent and involves facts similar to yours.  Persuasive authority is crucial if there is no mandatory authority on your issue.

Weak persuasive authority. That 1974 Iowa Court of Appeals opinion interpreting a statute that’s phrased similarly to the New York law you’re working with? Let it go. Remember it fondly for the headnote you discovered and then searched in New York, which led you to that 2013 New York Appellate Court opinion.

Origin stories. The very first case that articulates a rule can deepen your understanding of the law and its development. Finding a case like this demonstrates the thoroughness of your research, and is especially valuable if it’s from the highest court in your state – or SCOTUS.

Older cases that say the same things as newer cases. Let’s say you have two cases from your jurisdiction that apply the same rule to similar facts and reach the same outcome. One case is from 1989, the other from 2010. Keep the 21st century opinion.

Reversed/Overturned Cases. Put aside anything that’s been reversed or overturned. Label it clearly so you don’t use it by mistake.

Secondary sources. Hold on to these for reference, but do not cite them in your memo. They helped you find and understand the law, but they really are secondary now.

— – —

Want more law school tips? Sign up for our free mailing list today.

Other helpful law school tips:

  • Researching Your Open Memo: Finding One Good Case
  • Want to Get Good Law School Grades – Become a Self-Starter
  • Have You Visited the Academic Support Office Yet? 
  • How to Think Like a Successful Law Student

Photo Credit: Shutterstock


 

Looking for some help to do your best in law school? Find out about our law school tutoring options.


About Doretta McGinnis

Doretta McGinnis is a law school tutor for Law School Toolbox. After graduating from Harvard, she worked in academic publishing until a friend dared her to go to law school. Doretta earned her JD at Penn Law, where she was an editor of the University of Pennsylvania Law Review and a legal writing instructor. Eager to pay off her student loans, she practiced labor and employment law at a major Philadelphia law firm, but soon left Biglaw to pursue her interest in legal education. Doretta joined the faculty at Widener University Delaware Law School, where, over the course of nearly 20 years, she served as Associate Director of the legal writing program and taught labor law, employment discrimination, and bar exam prep. She is the co-founder of Admission Logic, LLC, an independent educational consulting practice focused on college and law school admissions.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  • Podcast
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

About Us

If you find law school tough, you are not alone! The Law School Toolbox team is here to help you through it. Check out our helpful free content, podcasts, courses and one-on-one tutoring. Thanks for stopping by and drop us a line if you have any questions. We also invite you to join our weekly mailing list, for advice right to your inbox.

Recent Posts

Podcast Microphone

Podcast Episode 343: Listen and Learn — Personal Jurisdiction (Civ Pro)

Welcome back to the Law School Toolbox podcast! In today's "Listen and Learn" episode, we look at the various ways of establishing whether a court has … Read More about Podcast Episode 343: Listen and Learn — Personal Jurisdiction (Civ Pro)

Use upperclass law students as resources: a list of questions you can ask

Use Upperclass Law Students as Resources: A List of Questions You Can Ask

Throughout law school, I have discovered things that are mysterious and tedious: from taking exams to choosing extracurriculars, from searching for … Read More about Use Upperclass Law Students as Resources: A List of Questions You Can Ask

Podcast Microphone

Podcast Episode 342: Real World Summer Job Situations (w/Sadie Jones)

Welcome back to the Law School Toolbox podcast! Today, we're talking with ex-BigLaw recruiter Sadie Jones about how to deal with difficult work … Read More about Podcast Episode 342: Real World Summer Job Situations (w/Sadie Jones)

How to Outline a Complex Legal Research Memo

How to Outline a Complex Legal Research Memo

At some point in law school, you’ll be asked to draft a complex legal memo whether for a class, a clinic, a job, or an internship. This involves … Read More about How to Outline a Complex Legal Research Memo

Podcast Microphone

Podcast Episode 341: Listen and Learn — Contract Defenses

Welcome back to the Law School Toolbox podcast! In today's episode, we're talking about contract defenses, including mistake, fraudulent … Read More about Podcast Episode 341: Listen and Learn — Contract Defenses

Want Better Law School Grades?

Sign Up for Our Exam Tips!

Footer

  • Podcast
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • Tutoring
  • Courses
  • Job Help
  • About
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Refunds

Copyright 2022 Law School Toolbox®™